Friday, 9 October 2015

REVIEW: CARRY ON BY RAINBOW ROWELL

Carry On by Rainbow Rowell

Published by: St. Martin's Griffin

Genre: YA Fantasy/Paranormal

Release date: October 6th 2015

Purchase: Amazon / B&N

    
     
Rainbow Rowell continues to break boundaries with Carry On, an epic fantasy following the triumphs and heartaches of Simon and Baz from her beloved bestseller Fangirl.

Simon Snow just wants to relax and savor his last year at the Watford School of Magicks, but no one will let him. His girlfriend broke up with him, his best friend is a pest, and his mentor keeps trying to hide him away in the mountains where maybe he’ll be safe. Simon can’t even enjoy the fact that his roommate and longtime nemesis is missing, because he can’t stop worrying about the evil git. Plus there are ghosts. And vampires. And actual evil things trying to shut Simon down. When you’re the most powerful magician the world has ever known, you never get to relax and savor anything.

Carry On is a ghost story, a love story, a mystery and a melodrama. It has just as much kissing and talking as you’d expect from a Rainbow Rowell story — but far, far more monsters. 

MY REVIEW:




What is this novel about? I think that you need to read Fangirl to truly understand Rainbow Rowell's inspiration behind this novel. Carry On is fictional story based on fictional fanfiction character (from Fangirl) which was inspired by fanfiction of real-life-famous fictional series (Harry Potter). Confusing, right? That's why I recommend reading Fangirl first because I don't think that Carry On stands on its own.


This book was a big challenge for me. I don't read M/M books so I took a risk reading this one. But Carry On is so much more than just M/M book (romance is not the only focus of the story). I was sooo extremely curious to find out more about Simon & Baz after reading Fangirl that I simply could not resist this book. All the tension between Simon & Baz and enemies-to-lovers trope worked perfectly in this case and I truly enjoyed myself. Sad thing is that we get to experience the pining on the Baz's side (book has multiple POVs) but we don't get to see how Baz fell in love...

Which leads me to another thing - storytelling. It took me very long time until characters grew on me. Was it because I was thrown basically in the middle of the story (end of "series") and didn't have time to properly build personal relationship with Simon and other characters? Fortunately, all three main characters were complex and interesting enough and eventually, they won me over. Also, banters were a lot of fun which is always a big plus for me!



Carry On has its minuses as well. It is character driven story which generally speaking I have no problem with. However, when reading Carry On, I kept wishing for more action which I love in fantasy/paranormal novels. But when it comes to a big picture, I have to admit that after reading Fangirl and Carry On I'm finally becoming fond of Rainbow Rowell's writing style and I do hope she decides to write more fantasy oriented books in the future. Recommended.

WHAT DO YOU THINK ABOUT FICTION ABOUT FICTIONAL FANFICTION?
ARE YOU FAMILIAR WITH SIMON & BAZ FROM FANGIRL?

Never Miss a Post:

Follow
author image

Lucia @Reading Is My Breathing

Lucia is 29 years old passionate reader and reviewer who enjoys talking about all bookish things. Currently she lives in Prague, works in business industry and dreams of starting her own publishing company. Her weakness? She can never say no to cake, coffee or good novel.

Comments (22)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I can't wait for this book. I love Rainbow Rowell, and Fangirl is pretty much my favorite book of all time. I don't think I will care at all that the story isn't very much focusing on the fantasy aspect, as you say. The characters and the dialogues have always been what I love most about Rowell's books, so I'm sure I will enjoy Carry On just as much as her other novels. I'm glad you enjoyed it too, even if it was (only) a 3.5 star read for you. Maybe you'll become just as big a Rowell fan as me some day. :)
1 reply · active 494 weeks ago
If it is banters that you are after, that you won't be disappointed because they were the part of the book that I enjoyed the most :) Carry On was my third book by Rowell and I definitely plan to read more by her in the future (Famgilr is also my favorite by her).
Thanks, Arabella! :)
It's kinda interesting to know, that this book is basically a book about characters in another book that were inspired by characters in another book! Haha. I'm interested in this one for the fact that it is fantasy, and I want to know how this author will be doing that!
My recent post ARC Review: Sweet Temptation by Wendy Higgins
1 reply · active 494 weeks ago
Fantasy-wise, this is not one of the best books out there. But banters are just so good that I enjoyed reading Carry On. If you like Mrs. Rowell's writing, I think this book is worth a read.
I haven't read Fangirl yet although I do own it. But I am going to make sure I do before I embark on this one otherwise it sounds like it really just will be too confusing for me to be able to handle. I also don't usually read M/M romances so that will be a shot in the dark for me too if I do pick this one up.
1 reply · active 494 weeks ago
It was shot in the dark for me too but fortunatelly it worked in this case. But yeah, rather read Fangirl first. Thanks for stopping by :)
My recent post REVIEW: Carry On by Rainbow Rowell
I didn't really pay a lot of attention to the snippets from Carry On in Fangirl, but i'm definitely interested in reading this one! I'm glad you enjoyed it overall, I really hope that I do too
1 reply · active 494 weeks ago
If you are fan of Rowell's writing style, you should be able to enjoy Carry On as well :) Thanks for stopping by, Lara!
I really loved Fangirl, and I've read a few M/M stories that I've also adored, so I'm soooo excited for this! I think Carry On isn't going to be for everyone, especially because of the LGBT aspect of it, but I'm glad that even though you aren't a reader of M/M, you were still able to slightly enjoy this!
My recent post Dreamstrider ARC Review -- Rambled, Jumbled, Conflicted Feelings
1 reply · active 494 weeks ago
Yes, I was surprised how enjoyable this novel was. I think it is because it is YA, so there were no explicit M/M scenes. I hope you will love Carry On when you get to reading it, Tika :)
Great review on Carry On Lucia! I'm really looking forward to reading it because of the fun banter and the M/M romance.
My recent post Happy Indulgence is looking for co-bloggers!
1 reply · active 494 weeks ago
I hope you will enjoy it, Jeann :) Banter was golden!
Yeah I really hope this book is being marketed as a spin off to Fangirl, I don't think it would make any sense to the casual reader. I'm interested in this one, but I really wish Rowell would have made a Fangirl sequel! ><

Also is this book TECHNICALLY written by Kath?
1 reply · active 494 weeks ago
Firstly, to answer your question - NO, this is written not by Cath from Fangirl. It is written directly my Rainbow Rowell. She explains in aknowledgements that she wanted to about Simon & Baz as herself not as Cath.

I liked Fangirl better than this one. But I still think that Carry On is worth of reading.

Thanks for stopping by :)
Yeah, character driven stories are hard to pull off, I think the characters need to be strong enough and developed enough to carry the story on their own without too much outside action and it seems like that wasn't the case here, which is sad. I loved Fangirl and was always interested in Simon and Baz so I'll probably still check this out. Nice review!
My recent post Dark Tide by Jennifer Donnelly (Series Giveaway) #DarkTide
1 reply · active 494 weeks ago
When it comes to fantasy, I prefer worldbuilding and story-driven novels. And worldbuilding in Carry On was...well just rewritten Harry Potter. It was painfully obvious so I could not give it more than 3.5 stars.
However, I had fun with this novel and I still think it is worth reading so I hope you will enjoy it, Alise :)
Great review Lucia :) I'm looking forward to this one, I adored Fangirl because it reminded me of my time spent in fandom. It's almost like nostalgia I suppose, if that makes sense?

I do think this book needs 'READ FANGIRL FIRST' on the cover though, otherwise I'm sure it would be a very confusing entry to Rainbow Rowell's world lol
My recent post Book Review: Wendy Darling (Volume One: Stars) by Colleen Oakes
1 reply · active 494 weeks ago
Yes, it does make sense. I probably loved Fangirl for the same reason as you :) (I am still part of fanfom, reading a lof ot fanfictions so it was super easy to connect with Cath). and even this this is not as great as Fangirl, I was still able to enjoy it.
Interesting to read your review! I started this book about a month ago but I'm finding it a little difficult to truly get into - I just got to 'book 2'. I keep on picking it up to read only 20 or so pages then putting it down in favour of something else and I think what you said about a character driven story really hits the nail on the head what my problem is. I want to finish it.
My recent post My Favourite Places to Read
1 reply · active 472 weeks ago
Oh yes, this is very character driven story. But even though writing is great I understand your struggle. Paranormal/fantasy genre needs more than just nicely written character driven storyline....

Post a new comment

Comments by