Friday, 16 January 2015

ARC REVIEW: RED QUEEN BY VICTORIA AVEYARD

Red Queen by Victoria Aveyard

(The Red Queen Trilogy #1)

Published by: Orion

Genre: Young Adult Fantasy

Release date: February 10th 2015

     
      
The poverty stricken Reds are commoners, living under the rule of the Silvers, elite warriors with god-like powers.

To Mare Barrow, a 17-year-old Red girl from The Stilts, it looks like nothing will ever change.

Mare finds herself working in the Silver Palace, at the centre of those she hates the most. She quickly discovers that, despite her red blood, she possesses a deadly power of her own. One that threatens to destroy Silver control.

But power is a dangerous game. And in this world divided by blood, who will win?

MY REVIEW:




I'm very sorry to say that I won't be recommending this book to anyone. I was very excited to read this novel, but it turned out to be nothing but a disappointment for me. *sad face*

Silvers and Reds. Ruling powerful race and weaker serving race, divided by the color of blood. A main protagonist who finds herself among enemies, forced to be someone she is not while fighting for the memory of her beloved and joins terrorist organization which is trying to take ruling class down. Sounds familiar, right? That's because we read it all in Red Rising already. I know that it is hard to come up with completely unique premise but in this case, similarities were too strong and left me with the bad taste in my mouth. At the end, Red Queen turned out to be just a childish version of Red Rising and lacked the spark of thought-provoking dystopian novel I had expected it to be.

This story had a potential, there were glimmers of how good it could be if executed in different way with more attention to details and world-building. Because I wanted more. More information about society, more of its history and hierarchy. I wanted more of everything but it wasn't delivered. Author provided only basic information to get the story going but it wasn't enough for me. The lack of world-building led to the lack of emotional feelings towards characters (and story itself) on my part. So even though the writing was decent, I have to emphasize that storytelling skills were definitely lacking in this novel. When author wagers everything on banters, flirting and forming of shallow love triangle (square), it can't work. Especially, it can't work in dystopian novel. Not only I was left unsatisfied, but I was also quite bored while reading it.

Don't take me wrong, I love me some romance in books. Unfortunately, in this case it wasn't the kind of epic romance that would steal my breath away and made up for not so stellar storytelling. Heroine spent most of the time trying to save (get closer) to all the boys she was falling for and sorting her confusing teenage hormones, rather than paying attention to the bigger picture in the story. And that's one of the reasons why I couldn't take this novel seriously. 

Moreover, this book has one of my biggest peeves when it comes to reading. Every single male character heroine encountered was mesmerized by her as soon as he met her. I hate that. It always annoys me and ruins my reading experience since I have to constantly roll my eyes at the sheer stupidity of it. 

I know that this book is loved by many bloggers and will gain even more fans when it is released, but it didn't work for me. If you are the one to seek complex stories with well-thought-out storyline and elaborate world-building, than Red Queen is probably not for you either.

Never Miss a Post:

Follow

author image

Lucia @Reading Is My Breathing

Lucia is 29 years old passionate reader and reviewer who enjoys talking about all bookish things. Currently she lives in Prague, works in business industry and dreams of starting her own publishing company. Her weakness? She can never say no to cake, coffee or good novel.

Comments (22)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I love that cover!
I don't read much fantasy anymore but i used to love it. I'm sorry you didn't love this one. I'll pass, LOL :)
Great Review!!!
My recent post Winter by Frankie Rose (Callie Hart) ~ Re-Released with New Content!
1 reply · active 535 weeks ago
Thank you, Stacy! I love that cover too, it was what drew me into reading this book. Such a pitty it did not work for me, I really wanted to love it!
When reviews first popped up about this, they were all so positive. But now I keep hearing that this was just a flop :( I have an arc so I need to read and review this, but I'll lower my expectations, especially if the male characters are as annoying as you say. I can't deal with every single guy falling in love with the main character.

My recent post What’s in a Name? Hopefully Not Mine
1 reply · active 535 weeks ago
I also had big expectations based on all those raving early reviews, but it was a big miss for me once I picked it up. I truly struggled with this book. I will keep an eye open for your review, I am very curious to see what you will think about it, Bec!
I want to read this book without any spoiler so I will not read your review but when I read my copy of the book I will come back to read your review :)
1 reply · active 535 weeks ago
I always try to avoid spoilers in my reviews, but I know what you mean. Sometimes it is better to go into book completely blind :)
How sad! I have this on my wishlist and was really bummed to see that NetGalley only has it for AU or UK bloggers. Maybe I dodged a bullet there. Thanks for posting your honest opinion.
1 reply · active 535 weeks ago
I would suggest to check other reviews before completely giving up on this book. Most of my friends loved it and I am seem to be in minority with this negative opinon about this novel. But most importantly, thanks for stopping by and finding time to comment :)
SAD FACE but I understand!

I think what separates you and I is the fact that you've read Red Rising! I think a couple of others who've read that one didn't enjoy Red Queen either! I haven't read Brown yet *hides because I know you love his work* so this one just won me over!

I was kind of so intrigued by one certain character (which I won't say because everything is so damn spoilery lol) that I didn't really notice Mare, which is odd because well, she's the main character. But hey, reading is so subjective, yes? I loved reading your thoughts on this one Lucia! Fantastic review, dear! <3
My recent post Seeking Saturday's Read #21: Coming To Terms With Blogging Balance, Cancelled TV Shows and Tackling Mime Order
1 reply · active 535 weeks ago
Thank you, Jess! I know that you absolutely loved this book so it must have been painful for you to read this review. It is fascinating how differently we (readers) see individual books. But there is no fun in uniformity, right?

Anyway, I really think that reading or not reading Red Rising plays a big role in how poeple see this book. I wonder if I would feel differently about Red Queen if I read it before Red Rising...
I've been hearing mixed things, which is a shame because the blurb is great. I am a big fan of world building, so the fact that this book has very little and is so heavily ruled by instant romance is a bit of a deal breaker. At least I don't feel so bad about not getting an arc now.
My recent post Generation V, Iron Night, and Tainted Blood by ML Brennan
1 reply · active 535 weeks ago
Yeah, this was romance driven story and it doesnt work in dystopian genre in my opinion. It focused too much on immature romance feelings instead of storytelling. So if you requere great world-building, this is probably not for you :/
Aw man, what a disappointment. :(
There's just been so much hype surrounding this one that I assumed that it had to be epic! But I'm going to have to go into it with an open mind because a book is never for everyone. Thank you for sharing Lucia!
1 reply · active 534 weeks ago
My review is very subjective. There were elements that I know many readers will love. However, this novel did not have what I seek in dystopian/fantasy books :( hopefully you will enjoy it better than I did, Laura!
Like you, I think this will gain popularity once it is released, but like you, I wasn't completely enamored with it. When I read it, it also made me think it resembled Red Rising so much. And the wishy-washy romance really was absurd. I mean later on it becomes clearer, but in the build-up before the "reveal" was simply annoying.

My recent post Review: The Unbecoming of Mara Dyer by Michelle Hodkin
1 reply · active 534 weeks ago
Yeah, similarities with Red Rising were just too noticable. I had no other choice but to compare and Red Queen was lacking in so many ways. And don't even start me on romance! It was so annoying... Thanks for stopping by, Faye :)
Hahahaha!! "Every single male character heroine encountered was mesmerized by her as soon as he met her."

Me TOO. Instead of highlighting the parts of this book that I liked/thought were clever, from like 2% in, I was highlighting the things that irritated me. A good third of them had to do with said memorization. When Red Guard chick said she wasn't going to plan a coup based on her little romance, and Guy #3 said, "I would," after looking at Mare forlornly, I nearly threw my kindle across the room. GAH.
1 reply · active 534 weeks ago
Agreed! This novel had more annoying parts than good ones. And that specific part you mentioned? It made my eyes roll big time. So bad!
Aww :( I was really hoping this one would be awesome. It had such an interesting concept. Sorry it was a bust! Hope your next read is a 5 :D
My recent post review: golden son by pierce brown
1 reply · active 530 weeks ago
Seems like this is a book people either love or hat. But since I know how big fun of Red Rising you are, there is big chance you will not enjoy this one either :/
YES, I'm so glad we could relate on this :) The ending alone was good, but overall the book is quite cliche and an unoriginal work. Thank you for the lovely, honest review x
My recent post Ugly Love by Colleen Hoover ♥ Review
1 reply · active 525 weeks ago
True. This one was very unoriginal and I wasn't fan of author's storytelling skills either... Glad to know someone agrees with me :)

Post a new comment

Comments by